India’s Budget for its Children

We just witnessed one of the country’s most interesting fortnights. One, it entailed the much-anticipated, first full-fledged, NaMo budget. Not soon after, the nation witnessed skeletons tumble out of its closet in the form of a BBC documentary – India’s daughter. Why mention both in the same breath, one might wonder?

The documentary, India’s daughter, as any educated, liberal mind would opine, is a clear reflection of the gross inequalities that persist in our system. From gender discrimination, abuse, poverty, closed and crude mindsets, it has reflected all and how it’s interlinked. It isn’t surprising then that the government (though of course one expected more from the current government) clamped down on viewing the documentary.

Why truth must not be faced as it is and when will we stop pretending to believe that all is well with our society? The country has one of the largest number of unemployed youth, one of the largest number of people living below poverty lines and in despicable living conditions, one of the largest out-of-school children in the world, and an alarming decline in the sex ratio especially during a period of unprecedented economic growth.  In the same breadth it also has the lowest spending on education in the world!

Educationists and activists were hence eagerly anticipating the budget wondering if the government ‘for change’ would finally allot the requisite funds towards educating the country’s children? Our future.  So, do we have reasons to rejoice? Unfortunately, not many.

Though some nominal measures have been undertaken that must be rather appreciated, such as  - Skill India Programme, the Deen Dayal Upadhyay Gramin Kaushal Yojana (for increasing employment among rural from 18-35 years), the Sukanya Samriddhi Scheme (part of the Beti Bachao Beti Padhao' campaign), proposal of setting up a fully IT-based Student Financial Aid Authority to administer education loans and scholarships to poor and middle class students for pursuing higher education.

There wasn’t much of a mention of a planned roadmap to tackle critical issues in school and higher education. The quality of education from school to higher education, dearth of qualified and trained teachers, Lack of crucial policies, lack of clarity on existing ones such as the Right to Education Act and the political will to implement them. We require increased and mapped outlays for sure to get the vast population of youth and children under one roof and a review of work done to ensure if we are on track or dreaming things up. Merely allotting an IIM or AIIMS is far from over when the current IIMs and IIT s are struggling to get qualified teachers and some, even students! Hence, the budget seems to have looked at the macro issues while being impatient to dig in deeper, which is required on an urgent basis.

A 16% cut in the outlay to education (compared to last fiscal) is a tad disappointing since now is the time to increase outlay to education and ensure to strengthen groundwork at schools, tighten and make the transition between schools to college and higher education thereafter more smooth and dynamic. Vocational education and skill building courses undoubtedly should be encouraged.

While we may choose to close our eyes and pretend all’s well, the truth is that depravity will only continue to thrive among inequalities or the varied ‘degrees of unfreedom’, as Amartya Sen would put it. We need to truly empower both India’s daughters and India’s sons to reach the best of their potential by working alongside and respecting each other and work toward a FREE and EMPOWERED Nation, free of biases, rituals, intolerance, poverty and self-fulfilling prophesies.   

Empowering Youth – Where Are Our Schools Faltering?

A close friend recently remarked how she has finally made up her mind about dropping out her 13 year old child from a respectable international school and homeschool him. She consulted a large, prominent homeschooling parents group and has now decided to take the plunge.  Schools, she said “were killing my child’s creativity and just providing literacy skills”. She had switched three schools successively and was very unhappy with the quality of education being imparted in schools and its core values. Incidentally, she was already the third parent I knew who would be doing so, joining the ranks of a growing tribe of parents home-schooling their children.  Needless to say, being an educator placing utmost importance on developing of every individual holistically and as true to self, I was perturbed.  Is formal education failing our children?

These were some of the most respectable schools in Mumbai forming the league of new-age international schools, reputed private schools and not public schools or government schools which continues to witness a large exodus of students leaving studies in spite of the RTE Act. (According to reports, in primary school education, the drop-out rate has increased to 0.97% from 0.58% in 2011-12 due to well-established factors like ignorance among parents, responsibilities at home, inaccessibility of schools, disengaging curriculum, migration etc.) Failure of public education system is well documented due to government schools plagued with teacher absenteeism, low teacher morale, crumbling infrastructure and an archaic curriculum which fails to engage students from communities already battling many issues.

However, what about private schools? With the dawn of the new age international schools, low student teacher ratio, holistic development and assessment, great infrastructure, learner-centric modules were introduced. Issues plaguing the traditional education system of rote learning and evaluating students unidimensionally on archaic irrelevant knowledge seemed to have gotten a shot in the arm. However, with thousands of such schools springing up everywhere, lack of effective regulation, dearth of quality teachers, even the better known schools are struggling with learning outcomes. The need for a dynamic system is imperative since education is always in a state of continuity. It is indeed ironical therefore that an institution which has the unparalleled challenge of predicting future needs of a society and moulding the aspirations and skills that will drive it must mould children within set, rigid frameworks.

It isn’t any wonder then that an increasing number of parents and students are getting disenchanted and questioning the method of getting educated. While homeschooling was born due to this gap and has met with much success (though its connotations vary), not many can afford to dedicate the resources in terms of time and money. Do we then have a solution? Renowned academicians and successful personalities have openly questioned the efficacy of mass schooling – an invention of the Industrial Era to train people to work in industries, mould their mindsets and skills from the manual labour they were used to in the Agricultural era. With changing times and the current Information Age, is the current education system run its course? What is education and how must its outcomes be measured?  In this knowledge economy it is undoubtedly the skills of the people that will propel growth of societies and nations.

That we are still grappling with achieving 100% basic literacy in the country is of course a matter of shame. However, what is equally perturbing is that even our graduates and postgraduates from well-reputed colleges are finding it difficult to get employed.  A recent study highlighted that while India has among the highest number of engineers graduating, a meagre 10% was found to be employable. Which means the education of 90% engineers isn’t worth a dime! And this is the scenario of typically every professional and graduate degree course. Clearly, we need to evolve fast! Merely paying lip service to education –as defined eons ago -- isn’t going to take us further.

We need to rehaul the entire education system which would truly empower every child irrespective of socio-economic background to reach his/her potential. Schools must be lively, dynamic, interactive bodies perpetuating creativity and not stifling it. We need to encourage children to learn at their own pace, do away with age criteria to write board exams, focus on imparting skills-based education and change assessment patterns which only tests linguistic and literacy prowess of children. We need to interweave the systematic study of the arts especially fine arts and performing arts.

A child is constantly learning – from his environment, school, parents, friends, nature… Why then seek education within the four walls of a classroom alone? Learning should be fun. According to the US Census Bureau by 2025 India is set to surpass China as the largest country with largest proportion in the working age category. This demographic dividend is expected to add 2 percentage points per annum to India’s per capita GDP growth. Can we imagine the contribution of an empowered youth comprising thinkers, innovators, entrepreneurs, artists, activists, writers, skilled force in the coming years? This requires a drastic change in the mind-sets of all stakeholders. We need to work as partners – the parents, the school and the state.  It was a wise person who said ‘It takes a village to raise a child.’